The Arizona Cardinals invested a No. 3 overall pick in running back Jeremiyah Love. That decision hasn't paid off, as Love remains sidelined with a high-ankle sprain. But even when Love has been available, he hasn't been as effective as one would hope given the steep draft investment.
We've seen the talent at Notre Dame, but it's more so a matter of the Cardinals failing to put him, or any running back for that matter, in a position to succeed.
Cardinals need to invest in Jeremiyah Love by upgrading the trenches
Tyler Allgeier has just 383 rushing yards and two rushing touchdowns on the season, a total that's even inflated with an outlier 147-yard performance in Arizona's comeback overtime win against the Dallas Cowboys.
Injuries have played a role, most notably former No. 6 overall pick Paris Johnson Jr., who is out for the season after tearing his biceps. However, GM Monti Ossenfort still needs to prioritize the offensive line more going forward. Johnson was one of Ossenfort's rare draft hits during his tenure. It was also the very first pick of his tenure taking over in 2023. That shows you how little success he's had in the draft, which has kept the Cardinals in this seemingly endless rebuilding cycle.
Marvin Harrison Jr. was the most frustrating miss, with Ossenfort at least essentially admitting that mistake by turning him into future draft capital from the Houston Texans. But now the jury is still out on his latest top-five draft investment, Love, at midseason.
He still has plenty of time to pan out, and it's not like the Cardinals have realistic playoff aspirations this season anyway. Still, Ossenfort's drafting track record and Love's slow start should concern fans. Not to mention, the Cardinals could've played it safer by selecting a more valuable position with Ohio State linebacker Arvell Reese, who is currently thriving with the New York Giants.
It's a bold bet for Arizona to take a running back that high in the draft, given how replaceable the position is. Love needs to be in a high tier to return value on that selection. That will never happen, regardless of how talented he is, until Arizona finally addresses its protection issues.
They should still strongly consider selecting a quarterback in the first round of this upcoming draft. But tiers are also emerging, with Oklahoma State's Drew Mestemaker separating himself from the rest of the quarterback prospects. Oregon's Dante Moore is out for the year, while Texas' Arch Manning has struggled, for instance.
Cardinals select LSU tackle Jordan Seaton in ESPN's latest mock
The Cardinals may be winning too many games for Mestemaker to be an option. Notre Dame's CJ Carr is a more realistic option that could be within their range and is certainly worth strong consideration. But in the latest 2027 NFL Mock Draft released by ESPN's Jordan Reid, the Cardinals decide to pass on Carr to help upgrade the trenches.
Arizona selects LSU tackle Jordan Seaton with the No. 7 overall pick, with Carr going just one spot after to the Atlanta Falcons. Reid calls it a seamless plug-and-play starting tackle opposite Johnson. That would finally give the Cardinals the infrastructure they need to support whoever that incoming quarterback may be.
Carr may be an upgrade over Carson Beck, but would he succeed with this line? We haven't seen veterans like Jacoby Brissett or Gardner Minshew II do it, and it's unlikely he could either. Plus, as Reid notes, the knock on Carr as a prospect is the lack of high-end traits, suggesting he doesn't quite have the star ceiling.
The quarterbacks coming out of college have been relatively underwhelming this season, putting the Cardinals in a tough spot with their projected top ten pick. They desperately need a quarterback, but also shouldn't force it. After all, they still need to continue investing in this Love pick to make sure he doesn't turn into the next Harrison. The best way to do that and finally establish a legitimate ground game in the desert is to invest in those trenches with someone like Seaton.
